MTA, NYPD disagree over subway crime messaging


NEW YORK — “Stand clear of the closing doors” is the advice that begins every subway trip.

But MTA officials have a warning as well: Be alert.

Some MTA board members questioned NYPD crime stats presented at their monthly board meeting. The overall percentage of crime is lower, according to the numbers. But assaults are up and with fewer riders taking the train.

The discussion went back and forth for about a half hour. Board members and officials want more detailed data.

“To say we are fear mongering, that’s just not the case,” said NYC Transit Interim President Sarah Feinberg. “We are reflecting the riders worries and we need to address that.”

MTA officials referenced the recent customer survey of 33,000 riders; it indicated riders were more concerned with safety and harassment, not COVID-19 concerns.

Kathleen O’Reilly, NYPD’s Chief of Transit, calls these high profile but isolated incidents.

“We need to get the message out there that the subway is safe and keep repeating that,” she said.

Hundreds of more officers are on patrol and undercover in the system this year.

“If you look at the major stats, the crime numbers are up, especially when you account that the number of riders is down,” MTA Chairman Pat Foye said.

It’s a public relations battle as well which is a theme that has also come up related to the two-hour overnight closure and cleaning of the system. Foye says they have to reassure riders that safety and health are being addressed as they return to the system.

“Crime is up but the system is safe,” added Foye. “Both things are true.”

The NYPD Transit Bureau reviews the crime stats the same as other precincts as they deploy and respond to areas of concern. They say will step up the coordination with city homeless services.

Copyright 2021 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.